The long-sought goal of a cure for AIDS is inching closer
Jul 21st 2011 | from the print edition
AIDS researchers, many of whom have been meeting this week in Rome under the auspices of the International AIDS Society, are rightly pleased with the progress they have made. In particular, the use of antiretroviral drugs has not only revolutionised treatment of HIV infection, but also offers the prospect of stopping the spread of the virus. In a matter of weeks, these drugs reduce the number of viruses per millilitre of infected blood from millions to less than 50. That deals with both symptoms and infectivity. Unless a patient stops taking the drugs, or goes on to develop resistance to them, he can expect to live almost as long as an uninfected individual.
But good as they are at keeping viral levels low, antiretrovirals never destroy the virus completely and thus cure the patient once and for all. There are two reasons. One is that, although HIV reproduces mainly in immune-system cells called T-cells, it also lives in certain cells of the brain, gut and lymph nodes. In these cells it is protected from the drugs by mechanisms that are, as yet, not fully understood. The other is that even in T-cells it sometimes stops replicating and becomes dormant. Since antiretrovirals work by interfering with the process of replication, dormant viruses are immune to their effects. Take the drugs away, and when a dormant virus wakes up again it will rapidly reinfect the body it is in.
The search for a cure for AIDS, then, has led only to frustration. And calls by the conference’s organisers to renew that search might be regarded by old hands as little more than platitudes. But they are not, for there is a glimmer of hope on the horizon. To deal with dormant viruses several researchers are taking what sounds like a counterintuitive approach. They are trying to wake the viruses up and so boost, rather than reduce, the amount of active HIV in a patient’s body. Their reasoning is that the now-active viruses will either kill the cells they are in (and thus themselves) or encourage the immune system to attack those cells.
Wake-up call and the purging croton
One drug that promises to do this is interleukin-7. This substance, which is being tested in several clinical trials in America, occurs naturally in the body and in normal conditions encourages the proliferation of the T-cells that HIV invades. One of the causes of viral dormancy is that the T-cell the virus resides in is itself in a resting state. Such cells on sabbatical do not churn out many proteins of their own, so the virus cannot hijack the protein-manufacturing process—which is how it reproduces.
The idea is that a dose of interleukin-7 will nudge the T-cell—and therefore the virus—into wakefulness. And it seems to work. Robert Murphy of Northwestern University, in Illinois, who is leading one of the clinical trials, says blips of reawakened virus can indeed be seen in patients’ blood after a dose of interleukin-7. Whether subsequent treatment with antiretrovirals can then cleanse the immune system completely remains to be seen. But this is a promising start.
An alternative approach is to activate the virus directly, rather than activating the cell it is living in. This is a way of dealing with the second cause of HIV inactivation. The virus must copy its genes into the host cells’ chromosomes before these genes can be used. And sometimes, those genes become so tightly packed away within their host chromosome that they cannot be read by the cell’s DNA-transcription mechanism. To be activated they must be liberated from the chromosomal coils.
A group of agents called histone deacetylase inhibitors can help here, says Sharon Lewin, director of the infectious-diseases unit at Alfred Hospital in Melbourne, who is about to start a clinical trial of a histone-deacetylase inhibitor called SAHA. Histones are proteins that regulate DNA packing, and histone deacetylases are enzymes that control the way those proteins work. One of their effects is to keep HIV genes switched off. So inhibiting their activity should switch those genes back on.
Until now, SAHA has been tested only in cell cultures. These tests have found that it increases the expression of dormant HIV genes fivefold. Combining it with other agents, in particular one called prostratin, makes it even more effective—at least, in a Petri dish. Prostratin is thought to activate a protein that promotes replication of the virus. In a study led by David Schaffer and Adam Arkin of the University of California, Berkeley, around 80% of latent HIV became active in cell cultures treated with a combination of SAHA and prostratin. Preliminary research suggests that prostratin may also prevent copies of the purged virus which are circulating in the bloodstream from integrating themselves back into healthy immune cells.
More powerful variants of prostratin are now in the offing. In the past, the substance has been extracted directly from plants, and was available only in small quantities. In 2008, however, Paul Wender of Stanford University found a way of synthesising it from the oil of the purging croton plant, which is abundant, and he has gone on to create tweaked versions of the molecule that, he claims, are 1,000 times more potent than prostratin.
Although none of the studies published so far has managed to reactivate all of the dormant HIV in either a cell culture or a human being, they are still an encouraging step. And Dr Schaffer and Dr Arkin suspect that complete reactivation may not be necessary. If the new treatments miss latent copies of the virus that are hard to activate, then those copies may, in any case, pose less of a risk of reactivating and replicating naturally, because they are in a deeper state of dormancy.
Unfortunately, none of these drugs deals with the other part of the problem: the viruses in the brain, gut and lymph nodes. But many workers in the field think T-cell dormancy a more significant cause of relapse than HIV in such reservoir tissues. If it can be dealt with, that will be a huge step towards the ultimate desideratum of HIV research—a simple and effective cure.